Wednesday, October 21, 2026

Turning the Page

 

I'm waiting for my cookie.

The results came in.

I didn't make the longlist for the Page Turner Awards and that's okay.

No dramatic music accompanying this admission, no  mysterious raven tapping at my window to announce my literary misfortune.  Though, if a raven did appear, I would probably offer it some peanuts and ask whether it had any publishing connections.  You never know if you don't ask.

Was I disappointed?

Yes, I was.  I was both happy for the winners and disappointed for myself.  You can hold space for both of these feelings.

Disappointment is allowed.

On occasion I think there's an odd pressure on writers to be relentlessly positive about rejection.  We're supposed to smile graciously, congratulate everyone, and immediately declare the experience was wonderful and educational.

And it can be. 

But we're also allowed to be disappointed.  We're allowed to sit there for a moment, stare at the announcement, and think a four letter word.  Perhaps even indulge in some chocolate, a cookie, or a whole package of cookies depending on the severity of the literary catastrophe.

Not being selected doesn't mean that your experience was worthless.  It doesn't mean that the judges are wrong either. 

The thing we need to remember is that writing is subjective.

Stephen King, the master of horror, still gets negative reviews on his works.  One of his best works is considered The Shining.  On Amazon someone wrote that The Shining was "boring."  Another said they were "disappointed."  On the flip side someone called it "A fabulous read."  Another just said "excellent."

If Stephen King can't please everyone, what hope do the rest of us have?

Should Stephen King throw down his pen, unplug his keyboard, and take up competitive basket weaving?  Should we do the same?

Of course not.

Just because someone doesn't like your work doesn't mean it's bad.  It simply means that particular story didn't resonate with that reader.

And that's okay.

After all, even Stephen King can't frighten everyone.  Apparently, some people are immune to haunted hotels, murderous ghosts, and deeply questionable hospitality.

Congratulations are still in order.

I also want to congratulate the writers who did make it to the Page Turner Awards longlist.  Making it that far is a huge accomplishment.  I do truly hope they're enjoying their moments in the spotlight.

There is room in the literary world to celebrate someone else's success without treating it as evidence of our own failure.

Their names being on the lit doesn't mean that my stories have suddenly become worthless.

It simply means that this was their moment.

And perhaps another opportunity will be mine.

Writing careers have a funny habit of refusing to follow maps.

Rather inconsiderate of us, really.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Black Friday Agreement: Christmas has Invaded Again!

  Hallowe'en kids are a-holdin' the line... Those who do arts and crafts are exempt from this entry.  As a crafter myself I know how...